Today’s offering is perhaps the longest post I’ve done to date. As an artist, I found the process confronting and at times horrifying. It raises questions what will be called ‘art’ in the future, the extent to which human intervention is needed for art, and so much more.
Once you’ve read through my post, please leave a comment with your thoughts!
Taking a leap into the brave new world of AI, I decided to give it a test run. Here is the sequence of events:
I wrote a short poem and then asked ChatGPT to pretend it was a Professor of Literary Criticism and review the poem, and then and identify ways to improve the poem. The last AI task was to rewrite the poem using the improvements it had identified.
Firstly, here is the review of my original poem:
As a professor of literary criticism, analyzing this collaborative poem reveals a rich tapestry of emotional and thematic depth that warrants a nuanced examination. The poem navigates through a juxtaposition of external brightness against the internal turmoil of the speaker, a contrast that sets the stage for an exploration of self-discovery and existential contemplation.
The opening line, “Despite a bright day, I am lying here,” immediately establishes a dichotomy between the external world and the internal state of the speaker. This contrast is not just environmental but reflects a deeper, existential dissonance. The imagery of “thoughts like clouds, drifting far and near” further extends this motif, using natural elements to symbolize the transient and often uncontrollable nature of thought and emotion.
As the poem progresses, “Gathering like a storm, a growing dread,” intensifies the emotional landscape. The storm is both a literal gathering of clouds and a metaphor for the accumulating anxieties or challenges the speaker faces. The introduction of a “silver thread” amidst this turmoil introduces a classic metaphor for hope and guidance. This thread, despite its fragility, becomes a lifeline through the darkness, embodying the potential for redemption and clarity even in the most challenging times.
The journey toward self-discovery is encapsulated in the lines, “Fragile and thin, I reach for it / It leads me through the darkness, bit by bit.” These lines speak to the universal human experience of seeking purpose and understanding in moments of despair. The act of reaching for the “silver thread” suggests an innate resilience and willingness to confront one’s innermost fears and doubts.
The concluding lines, “Until I find myself, and don’t recognize / The reflection in the mirror, my own eyes,” reveal the poem’s culmination in an unexpected revelation. This moment of self-alienation is paradoxical yet profoundly resonant. It suggests that the journey inward does not always lead to familiar terrain; rather, it can reveal aspects of oneself that are unrecognizable, highlighting the transformative potential of introspection and emotional struggle.
In sum, this poem navigates the complex interplay between external reality and internal perception, utilizing vivid imagery and metaphors to explore themes of existential dread, hope, and self-discovery. The juxtaposition of hope against despair, the imagery of the storm and the silver thread, and the concluding revelation of self-alienation, all work cohesively to craft a poignant reflection on the human condition. Its brevity does not detract from its depth; rather, it encapsulates profound emotional experiences in a few, carefully chosen words, demonstrating the power of poetry to convey complex emotional landscapes succinctly and evocatively.
Losing Found Self
Despite a bright day, I am lying here,
With thoughts like clouds, drifting far and near.
Gathering like a storm, a growing dread,
Yet in this turmoil, a silver thread.
Fragile and thin, I reach for it,
It leads me through the darkness, bit by bit.
Until I find myself, but I do not recognise,
The reflection in the mirror, my own eyes.
And now for the AI Generated poem/art/words:
I write, therefore I am
Despite the sun’s embrace, I lie here still,
With thoughts like scattered leaves, blown wild and chill.
Dark clouds gather, a storm of fret and dread,
Within this tempest, a slender silver thread.
Fragile and gleaming, it cuts through the gloom,
I reach for it, a beacon in the doom.
Through shadowed valleys and peaks of despair,
It guides me, a whisper of hope in the air.
The path it weaves through the tumult and fear,
Brings me to a mirror, stark and clear.
I stand before it, a stranger to my own gaze,
The reflection altered by the journey’s maze.
Eyes that have seen the depths, now look back at me,
Changed, unrecognizable, yet undeniably free.
The storm still rages, but within, a light has grown,
Illuminating a self, newly known.
And below are the areas for improvement that ChatGPT identified for my wee little musing:
Improving a poem, especially one as nuanced as the one we’ve created, involves refining its imagery, deepening its thematic elements, and enhancing its emotional resonance. Here are several suggestions for enhancing the poem’s impact:
1. Enhance Imagery and Sensory Details
- Consider adding more vivid imagery or sensory details to deepen the reader’s emotional connection. For instance, the storm could be described in more detail to reflect the turmoil within the speaker, using sounds, colors, or sensations.
2. Introduce Symbolism
- The “silver thread” serves as a potent symbol of hope or guidance. Expanding this metaphor or introducing other symbols could enrich the poem’s layers of meaning. Symbols related to light, darkness, or nature might be particularly fitting.
3. Explore Internal Conflict
- The poem hints at an internal struggle but could delve deeper into this aspect. Perhaps adding lines that explore the speaker’s conflict or ambivalence would provide a more nuanced portrayal of their emotional state.
4. Refine the Turn or Shift
- Many poems include a turn or shift, a moment where the perspective or tone changes significantly. Enhancing the moment of realization or transformation towards the end could make the poem’s conclusion more impactful.
5. Incorporate Rhythmic Variation
- Playing with the poem’s rhythm and meter can add a musical quality and emphasize key moments. For example, shorter lines could speed up the pace, mirroring the speaker’s growing anxiety, while longer lines could slow it down, reflecting moments of introspection.
6. Use Repetition for Emphasis
- Repetition of key phrases or images can reinforce central themes or emotions. Consider repeating a significant word or line to underscore the poem’s main idea or the speaker’s emotional journey.
7. Clarify the Speaker’s Transformation
- The ending hints at a profound change in the speaker’s self-perception. Providing clearer insights into what has changed or how the speaker views themselves differently now could offer a stronger sense of closure.
8. Experiment with Form
- The poem’s form could be adapted to mirror its content. For example, a more fragmented structure could represent the speaker’s fragmented sense of self, while a more cohesive form might reflect moments of clarity or understanding.
9. Integrate Feedback
- Sharing the poem with others and soliciting feedback can provide new insights and perspectives. Sometimes, an external viewpoint can highlight areas for improvement or suggest new directions.
10. Reflect on Personal Experience
- If applicable, weaving in more personal experiences or emotions can add authenticity and depth. Even in collaborative or fictional poetry, elements drawn from genuine feelings or experiences can resonate more strongly with readers.
Improving a poem is a process of exploration and refinement. It’s about balancing clarity of expression with the richness of imagery and depth of emotion. Each revision presents an opportunity to delve deeper into the poem’s essence and enhance its ability to resonate with readers.
Angele Toomey Poetry 
Leave a comment